How to Tell a Real 16-bit Depth Map from a Stretched 8-bit One

A depth map PNG can say "16-bit" in its header and still carry only 8-bit information. For screen effects that rarely matters. For a laser engrave, a lithophane, or a CNC relief, it shows up as visible terraces.

The quick test

Count the distinct gray values.

from PIL import Image

im = Image.open("depth.png")
vals = list(im.getdata())
print(im.mode)            # I;16 for a 16-bit grayscale PNG
print(len(set(vals)))     # distinct height codes
print(min(vals), max(vals))

A stretched 8-bit file has 256 or fewer distinct values, and every value is a multiple of 257 (because 8-bit codes were multiplied by 257 to fill the 0–65,535 range). A genuine 16-bit field has thousands.

A measured example

The public dataset depthmap/16bit-vs-8bit-depth-maps contains the same lion-medallion height field three ways, measured with Pillow on 15 November 2026:

File Header Distinct values
lion-depth-16bit.png 16-bit 19,662 (min 0, max 19,661)
lion-depth-8bit.png 8-bit 77
lion-depth-8bit-upscaled-to-16bit.png 16-bit 77, all multiples of 257

The third file is the failure mode: the header says 16-bit, the count does not. Stretching 77 codes into a bigger container does not invent the missing steps.

Why the max is 19,661, not 65,535

That export was written on a 10 mm full scale (65,535 = 10 mm), and the relief was 3 mm deep. A 3 mm relief uses about a third of the range, so the brightest pixel lands near 19,661. On the same scale an 8-bit file only has 77 height steps for 3 mm, which is where the terracing comes from. A shallow relief like this can also look almost black in a normal image viewer; that is expected, not a broken file.

Where the sample came from

I made the 16-bit PNG and the matching closed STL with a depth map generator from one photograph, then derived the 8-bit and upscaled copies in the dataset so all three share one height field. The dataset includes verify.py so you can re-run the counts yourself, and a static Space, 16-bit vs 8-bit depth map guide, shows shaded side-by-side previews.

Checklist before you engrave or print

If any of those fail, regenerate or re-export rather than smoothing the terraces after the fact.